Skip to main content
replaced http://pets.stackexchange.com/ with https://pets.stackexchange.com/
Source Link

Just addressing the point about aquariums: I've seen it used for questions about keeping multiple fish species in one tank, and I agree it's not clear or helpful there. These questions often deal with topics that I don't think someone with a question* is likely to be interested in, like finding common environmental conditions, pet-on-pet predation, etc.

Some examples:

These are all tagged ; there are plenty of similar questions that are not, like Besides water quality, what should I consider before adding more tropical fish?Besides water quality, what should I consider before adding more tropical fish?.

I'd recommend we use something like for these instead. The common term for a tank with multiple species is a community aquarium so that might make more sense as a tag, though it might be more prone to misuse on questions where the species mix isn't really relevant.

*For the record, I think the tag is too ambiguous in general. It's not clear to me whether it's describing pet+pet interactions or the human-family side of having pets or what.

Just addressing the point about aquariums: I've seen it used for questions about keeping multiple fish species in one tank, and I agree it's not clear or helpful there. These questions often deal with topics that I don't think someone with a question* is likely to be interested in, like finding common environmental conditions, pet-on-pet predation, etc.

Some examples:

These are all tagged ; there are plenty of similar questions that are not, like Besides water quality, what should I consider before adding more tropical fish?.

I'd recommend we use something like for these instead. The common term for a tank with multiple species is a community aquarium so that might make more sense as a tag, though it might be more prone to misuse on questions where the species mix isn't really relevant.

*For the record, I think the tag is too ambiguous in general. It's not clear to me whether it's describing pet+pet interactions or the human-family side of having pets or what.

Just addressing the point about aquariums: I've seen it used for questions about keeping multiple fish species in one tank, and I agree it's not clear or helpful there. These questions often deal with topics that I don't think someone with a question* is likely to be interested in, like finding common environmental conditions, pet-on-pet predation, etc.

Some examples:

These are all tagged ; there are plenty of similar questions that are not, like Besides water quality, what should I consider before adding more tropical fish?.

I'd recommend we use something like for these instead. The common term for a tank with multiple species is a community aquarium so that might make more sense as a tag, though it might be more prone to misuse on questions where the species mix isn't really relevant.

*For the record, I think the tag is too ambiguous in general. It's not clear to me whether it's describing pet+pet interactions or the human-family side of having pets or what.

Added examples
Source Link
toxotes
  • 3.8k
  • 11
  • 6

Just addressing the point about aquariums: I've seen it used for questions about keeping multiple fish species in one tank, and I agree it's not clear or helpful there. These questions often deal with topics that I don't think someone with a question* is likely to be interested in, like finding common environmental conditions, pet-on-pet predation, etc.

Some examples:

These are all tagged ; there are plenty of similar questions that are not, like Besides water quality, what should I consider before adding more tropical fish?.

I'd recommend we use something like for these instead. The common term for a tank with multiple species is actually 'community aquariums'a community aquarium so that might make more sense as a tag, though it might be more prone to misuse on questions where the species mix isn't really relevant.

*For the record, I think the tag is too ambiguous in general. It's not clear to me whether it's describing pet+pet interactions or the human-family side of having pets or what.

Just addressing the point about aquariums: I've seen it used for questions about keeping multiple fish species in one tank, and I agree it's not clear or helpful there. These questions often deal with topics that I don't think someone with a question* is likely to be interested in, like finding common environmental conditions, pet-on-pet predation, etc.

I'd recommend we use something like for these instead. The common term is actually 'community aquariums' so that might make more sense as a tag, though it might be more prone to misuse on questions where the species mix isn't really relevant.

*For the record, I think the tag is too ambiguous in general. It's not clear to me whether it's describing pet+pet interactions or the human-family side of having pets or what.

Just addressing the point about aquariums: I've seen it used for questions about keeping multiple fish species in one tank, and I agree it's not clear or helpful there. These questions often deal with topics that I don't think someone with a question* is likely to be interested in, like finding common environmental conditions, pet-on-pet predation, etc.

Some examples:

These are all tagged ; there are plenty of similar questions that are not, like Besides water quality, what should I consider before adding more tropical fish?.

I'd recommend we use something like for these instead. The common term for a tank with multiple species is a community aquarium so that might make more sense as a tag, though it might be more prone to misuse on questions where the species mix isn't really relevant.

*For the record, I think the tag is too ambiguous in general. It's not clear to me whether it's describing pet+pet interactions or the human-family side of having pets or what.

Source Link
toxotes
  • 3.8k
  • 11
  • 6

Just addressing the point about aquariums: I've seen it used for questions about keeping multiple fish species in one tank, and I agree it's not clear or helpful there. These questions often deal with topics that I don't think someone with a question* is likely to be interested in, like finding common environmental conditions, pet-on-pet predation, etc.

I'd recommend we use something like for these instead. The common term is actually 'community aquariums' so that might make more sense as a tag, though it might be more prone to misuse on questions where the species mix isn't really relevant.

*For the record, I think the tag is too ambiguous in general. It's not clear to me whether it's describing pet+pet interactions or the human-family side of having pets or what.