3

The wiki for the tag says that it's:

About the obedience competition sport, where the dog is trained to perform a series of obedience exercices (heel work, scent discrimination, long duration downs, etc.).

However, it's not being used that way. Of the 46 questions using it, only the earliest one, Dog obedience scent discrimination, is unambiguously about the sport of canine obedience. One other, How do I teach my dog to jump over obstacles?, might apply because there are jumps in the higher levels of obedience competition (at least in the AKC version that I'm familiar with) even though the OP was more concerned with teaching their dog a skill than using that skill in competition.

The problem is that "obedience" means different things to different people. For people involved in the sport, it means the sport itself: "I'll be at the dog show next weekend. I've entered Fido in obedience and Rex in agility." For people uninvolved with the sport, it's the end-result of basic training.

I think a better tag for the sport would be (that phrase appears 94 times in the AKC Obedience Regulations so it will be familiar to practitioners), which opens its use to other animals and hopefully makes it clear that it doesn't mean basic training.

I also think that should be merged into the existing tag (after retagging the 7 questions that use but not ) since that's what the vast majority of the questions currently using it are actually about.

  • I see two upvotes and no down votes. If there is no response by next weekend, consider silence as consent and move forward. If there is anything you are not able to complete on your own, let me know. – James Jenkins Jan 29 '18 at 13:27
2

As James Jenkins suggested in the comment, no one ventured a counter-proposal and this seems like a great solution to the problem to me!

I have now done the following (as per your question):

Thanks for your suggestion and apologies it took me so long to implement it!

  • 1
    Typo alert: [obedience-trail] in the second bullet point should be [obedience-trial]. I'd suggest an edit but it's meta so I can't. :( Thanks for doing the legwork on this. – Cucamonga Mar 26 '18 at 4:39
  • Updated! Thanks for providing such a well thought out proposal! – Henders Mar 26 '18 at 8:17

You must log in to answer this question.

Not the answer you're looking for? Browse other questions tagged .